UK breaching international law over torture 'cover-up', says UN - The Libyan Report

UK breaching international law over torture 'cover-up', says UN

The UN has formally warned the UK its refusal to launch a judicial inquiry into torture and rendition breaches international law, The Independent can reveal.

UN special rapporteur for torture Nils Melzer accused the British government of covering up its involvement in the practices post-9/ 11, saying he suspects a cover-up organised to protect figures who are “very high up”.

He has written a private “intervention” letter to the foreign secretary challenging the refusal to investigate “credible” claims that UK officials have been involved in torture. He told this newspaper it appears the government has engaged in a conscious policy of cooperating with torture since 9/11, saying it is “impossible” the practice was not approved or at least tolerated by top officials.

We’ll tell you what’s true. You can form your own view. From 15p €0.18 $0.18 USD 0.27 a day, more exclusives, analysis and extras.

The letter says the UK government must hold a judicial inquiry and prosecute government officials found to be responsible, as it is bound by the UN Convention Against Torture to criminalise all acts of torture whenever there are credible grounds. Such grounds were established by evidence published by Parliament’s Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC) in 2018 which showed British intelligence agencies have been involved in torture and rendition cases since 9/11, the letter said.

“The interesting question is not whether the UK was involved in torture because you already have the evidence. You already have the Intelligence and Security Committee saying so,” Melzer told The Independent.

Shape Created with Sketch. UK news in pictures Show all 50 left Created with Sketch. right Created with Sketch. Shape Created with Sketch. UK news in pictures 1/50 10 October 2019 Irish Prime Minister Leo Varadkar and British Prime Minister Boris Johnson at Thornton Manor. Their meeting focused on further Brexit proposals EPA/Noel Mullen 2/50 9 October 2019 Wales survived an almighty scare against Fiji to secure quarter-final spot at the rugby world cup. Warren Gatland’s side recovered from a 10-0 deficit thanks to a hat-trick from Josh Adams AFP/Getty 3/50 8 October 2019 Protesters dubbed the Red Rebels at Millbank at the junction with Great College Street, during an Extinction Rebellion protest in Westminster PA 4/50 7 October 2019 Final preparations are made in front of a reproduction of Michelangelo's 'The Last Judgement', ahead of the opening of for the 'Michelangelo: A Different View' exhibition at Hull Minister PA 5/50 6 October 2019 A car drives through a flooded street in Whitley Bay in Northumberland PA 6/50 5 October 2019 Thousands took to the streets of Edinburgh today to march in support of a second Scottish independence referendum EPA 7/50 4 October 2019 A 12ft sculpture of a gorilla, entitled 'Gorilla Apocalypse', created by Luke Kite entirely from scrap car bumpers and panels discarded in the last decade is on display at the British Ironwork Centre in Oswestry, Shropshire PA 8/50 3 October 2019 Police stands in front of the Treasury building during an Extinction Rebellion protest in London Reuters 9/50 2 October 2019 Ex-Thomas Cook employees demonstrate in London after delivering a petition calling for a full inquiry into Thomas Cook's collapse and for the company's directors to pay back their bonuses AFP/Getty 10/50 1 October 2019 A road in Alum Rock, Birmingham is flooded after persistent heavy rain PA 11/50 30 September 2019 Two tourists pose for pictures in front of Union and EU flags outside the Houses of Parliament in London PA 12/50 29 September 2019 A sheep on London Bridge as Freemen of the City of London took up their historic entitlement to drive sheep over the bridge, which was once London's only river crossing PA 13/50 28 September 2019 An Aldabra giant tortoise is fed watermelon as a treat at the Malvern Autumn Show, at the Three Counties Showground near Malvern in Worcestershire PA 14/50 27 September 2019 Gallery assistants pose with an artwork entitled 'Devolved Parliament' by British artist Banksy, during a press view in London ahead of Sotheby's contemporary art sale, as part of the Frieze Art Fair AFP/Getty 15/50 26 September 2019 England's Jonathan Joseph is tackled by United State's Marcel Brache during their group match at the Rugby World Cup in Japan. England scored seven tries on their way to winning 45-7 Reuters 16/50 25 September 2019 Tributes for former Rangers player Fernando Ricksen at Ibrox Stadium. Today, the funeral procession will pass Ibrox Stadium before making the journey to Wellington Church PA 17/50 24 September 2019 A person dressed as a caricature of Prime Minister Boris Johnson in a prison uniform stands outside the Supreme Court after it ruled that his decision to suspend Parliament was illegal AFP/Getty 18/50 23 September 2019 Thomas Cook aircraft are parked up at Manchester Airport on the day they collapsed after rescue talks failed. A total of 22,000 jobs - including 9,000 in UK - are to be lost following administration. More than 150,000 British holidaymakers need to be brought home, with the government and CAA hiring dozens of charter planes to fly customers home free of charge Getty 19/50 22 September 2019 Fire performer Penella Bee performs before people take part in the North East Skinny Dip at Druridge Bay in Nothumberland, an annual event that marks the Autumn Equinox and raises money for MIND - the Mental Health Charity PA 20/50 21 September 2019 Protesters gather for a march and rally organised by "The People's Vote" in Brighton, to call for politicians to give the public a final say referendum on Brexit AFP/Getty 21/50 20 September 2019 Protesters in London joined millions across world to demand urgent action to save planet in the largest environmental protest in history Angela Christofilou/The Independent 22/50 19 September 2019 Rapper Dave poses with the Mercury Prize: Albums of the Year Award at Apollo Getty 23/50 18 September 2019 A surfer in action during sunrise at Tynemouth on the north east coast PA 24/50 17 September 2019 Protesters dressed as the Incredible Hulk and Robocop outside the Supreme Court in London where judges are due to consider legal challenges to Prime Minister Boris Johnson's decision to suspend Parliament. The Supreme Court will hear appeals over three days from two separate challenges to the prorogation of Parliament brought in England and Scotland PA 25/50 16 September 2019 Farmer Tom Hoggard harvests pumpkins at Howe Bridge Farm in Yorkshire, ahead of Halloween PA 26/50 15 September 2019 Team Europe celebrate winning the Solheim Cup at Gleneagles in Auchterarder, Scotland. Europe won the last three singles matches to claim victory 14½-13½ Getty 27/50 14 September 2019 Sunset at St Mary's Lighthouse in Whitley Bay PA 28/50 13 September 2019 Activists from PETA stage a demonstration outside a venue during London Fashion Week in London, Britain Reuters 29/50 12 September 2019 Australia's Marnus Labuschagne attempts to stop a boundary in the fifth Test Action Images via Reuters 30/50 11 September 2019 Storm clouds gather over the pier just off the North East coast at South Shields PA 31/50 10 September 2019 The peloton rides past the Angel of the North during stage four of the Tour of Britain from Gateshead to Kendal PA 32/50 9 September 2019 A penny farthing cyclist rides past St. John's, Smith Square, Westminster, London PA 33/50 8 September 2019 Australia celebrate the wicket of England's Craig Overton, which meant they won the fourth test and retained the Ashes Action Images via Reuters 34/50 7 September 2019 Manchester City celebrate after Caroline Weir scored during their Women's Super League match against Manchester United at Etihad Stadium. The WSL attendance record was smashed with 31,213 people watching the first Manchester derby of Women’s Super League era – nearly six times the previous WSL record Getty 35/50 6 September 2019 A bull bumps into a plain clothes police officer (left) while being walked by Prime Minister Boris Johnson during his visit to Darnford Farm in Banchory near Aberdeen. It coincided with the publication of Lord Bew's review and an announcement of extra funding for Scottish farmers PA 36/50 5 September 2019 First Minister Nicola Sturgeon cuts the hair of David Torrance MSP raising £1000 for the charity Maggie's Centre in Kirkcaldy at the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh PA 37/50 4 September 2019 Australia's David Warner looks dejected after being dismissed by England's Stuart Broad during day one of the fourth Ashes Test at Old Trafford in Manchester Getty 38/50 3 September 2019 Anti Brexit demonstrators attend a protest at Parliament Square. Lawmakers returned from their summer recess Tuesday for a pivotal day in British politics as they challenged Prime Minister Boris Johnson's insistence that the UK leave the European Union on 31 October, even without a withdrawal agreement to cushion the economic blow AP 39/50 2 September 2019 Set building begins on Waterloo Place in Edinburgh ahead of filming for Fast and Furious 9 PA 40/50 1 September 2019 Members of the Royal Southern Yacht Club and the Island Sailing Club take part during the annual cricket match between the clubs, which takes place on the Bramble Bank sandbank in the middle of the Solent at low tide PA 41/50 31 August 2019 Anti-Brexit protesters demonstrate at Whitehall in London SWNS 42/50 30 August 2019 One of the iconic 'Girl with Balloon' artworks by anonymous street artist Banksy is carried near one of the original locations the artwork appeared at on the Southbank in London AP 43/50 29 August 2019 The sun rises over the sculpture "The Couple" by artist Sean Henry, at Newbiggin-by-the-sea in Northumberland PA 44/50 28 August 2019 A person wearing a Boris Johnson 'head' digs a grave at the foot of a tombstone during a protest organised by Avaaz and Best for Britain, outside Downing Street in London PA 45/50 27 August 2019 Nat Lofthouse statue is covered in flags at the University of Bolton Stadium, Bolton Action Images via Reuters 46/50 26 August 2019 Performers take part in Notting Hill Carnival. Nearly one million people were expected to attend Sunday and Monday's carnival to celebrate Caribbean culture AFP/Getty 47/50 25 August 2019 A competitor swims in the World Bog Snorkelling Championships in Llanwryd Wells, Powys Reuters 48/50 24 August 2019 People flock to Bournemouth beach as a heatwave spells potentially record high temperatures for the bank holiday weekend PA 49/50 23 August 2019 Fans of Bury FC deliver a symbolic coffin to the club's home at Gigg Lane as the continuation of their membership to the football league lies in doubt. The club will lose their membership at midnight if they don't find a buyer or prove that they have the means to pay off their debts PA 50/50 22 August 2019 Labour Leader Jeremy Corbyn and Shadow DEFRA Secretary Sue Hayman during a visit to Rakefoot Farm, Castlerigg, Keswick where they are highlighting the danger of a No Deal Brexit to sheep farmers PA 1/50 10 October 2019 Irish Prime Minister Leo Varadkar and British Prime Minister Boris Johnson at Thornton Manor. Their meeting focused on further Brexit proposals EPA/Noel Mullen 2/50 9 October 2019 Wales survived an almighty scare against Fiji to secure quarter-final spot at the rugby world cup. Warren Gatland’s side recovered from a 10-0 deficit thanks to a hat-trick from Josh Adams AFP/Getty 3/50 8 October 2019 Protesters dubbed the Red Rebels at Millbank at the junction with Great College Street, during an Extinction Rebellion protest in Westminster PA 4/50 7 October 2019 Final preparations are made in front of a reproduction of Michelangelo's 'The Last Judgement', ahead of the opening of for the 'Michelangelo: A Different View' exhibition at Hull Minister PA 5/50 6 October 2019 A car drives through a flooded street in Whitley Bay in Northumberland PA 6/50 5 October 2019 Thousands took to the streets of Edinburgh today to march in support of a second Scottish independence referendum EPA 7/50 4 October 2019 A 12ft sculpture of a gorilla, entitled 'Gorilla Apocalypse', created by Luke Kite entirely from scrap car bumpers and panels discarded in the last decade is on display at the British Ironwork Centre in Oswestry, Shropshire PA 8/50 3 October 2019 Police stands in front of the Treasury building during an Extinction Rebellion protest in London Reuters 9/50 2 October 2019 Ex-Thomas Cook employees demonstrate in London after delivering a petition calling for a full inquiry into Thomas Cook's collapse and for the company's directors to pay back their bonuses AFP/Getty 10/50 1 October 2019 A road in Alum Rock, Birmingham is flooded after persistent heavy rain PA 11/50 30 September 2019 Two tourists pose for pictures in front of Union and EU flags outside the Houses of Parliament in London PA 12/50 29 September 2019 A sheep on London Bridge as Freemen of the City of London took up their historic entitlement to drive sheep over the bridge, which was once London's only river crossing PA 13/50 28 September 2019 An Aldabra giant tortoise is fed watermelon as a treat at the Malvern Autumn Show, at the Three Counties Showground near Malvern in Worcestershire PA 14/50 27 September 2019 Gallery assistants pose with an artwork entitled 'Devolved Parliament' by British artist Banksy, during a press view in London ahead of Sotheby's contemporary art sale, as part of the Frieze Art Fair AFP/Getty 15/50 26 September 2019 England's Jonathan Joseph is tackled by United State's Marcel Brache during their group match at the Rugby World Cup in Japan. England scored seven tries on their way to winning 45-7 Reuters 16/50 25 September 2019 Tributes for former Rangers player Fernando Ricksen at Ibrox Stadium. Today, the funeral procession will pass Ibrox Stadium before making the journey to Wellington Church PA 17/50 24 September 2019 A person dressed as a caricature of Prime Minister Boris Johnson in a prison uniform stands outside the Supreme Court after it ruled that his decision to suspend Parliament was illegal AFP/Getty 18/50 23 September 2019 Thomas Cook aircraft are parked up at Manchester Airport on the day they collapsed after rescue talks failed. A total of 22,000 jobs - including 9,000 in UK - are to be lost following administration. More than 150,000 British holidaymakers need to be brought home, with the government and CAA hiring dozens of charter planes to fly customers home free of charge Getty 19/50 22 September 2019 Fire performer Penella Bee performs before people take part in the North East Skinny Dip at Druridge Bay in Nothumberland, an annual event that marks the Autumn Equinox and raises money for MIND - the Mental Health Charity PA 20/50 21 September 2019 Protesters gather for a march and rally organised by "The People's Vote" in Brighton, to call for politicians to give the public a final say referendum on Brexit AFP/Getty 21/50 20 September 2019 Protesters in London joined millions across world to demand urgent action to save planet in the largest environmental protest in history Angela Christofilou/The Independent 22/50 19 September 2019 Rapper Dave poses with the Mercury Prize: Albums of the Year Award at Apollo Getty 23/50 18 September 2019 A surfer in action during sunrise at Tynemouth on the north east coast PA 24/50 17 September 2019 Protesters dressed as the Incredible Hulk and Robocop outside the Supreme Court in London where judges are due to consider legal challenges to Prime Minister Boris Johnson's decision to suspend Parliament. The Supreme Court will hear appeals over three days from two separate challenges to the prorogation of Parliament brought in England and Scotland PA 25/50 16 September 2019 Farmer Tom Hoggard harvests pumpkins at Howe Bridge Farm in Yorkshire, ahead of Halloween PA 26/50 15 September 2019 Team Europe celebrate winning the Solheim Cup at Gleneagles in Auchterarder, Scotland. Europe won the last three singles matches to claim victory 14½-13½ Getty 27/50 14 September 2019 Sunset at St Mary's Lighthouse in Whitley Bay PA 28/50 13 September 2019 Activists from PETA stage a demonstration outside a venue during London Fashion Week in London, Britain Reuters 29/50 12 September 2019 Australia's Marnus Labuschagne attempts to stop a boundary in the fifth Test Action Images via Reuters 30/50 11 September 2019 Storm clouds gather over the pier just off the North East coast at South Shields PA 31/50 10 September 2019 The peloton rides past the Angel of the North during stage four of the Tour of Britain from Gateshead to Kendal PA 32/50 9 September 2019 A penny farthing cyclist rides past St. John's, Smith Square, Westminster, London PA 33/50 8 September 2019 Australia celebrate the wicket of England's Craig Overton, which meant they won the fourth test and retained the Ashes Action Images via Reuters 34/50 7 September 2019 Manchester City celebrate after Caroline Weir scored during their Women's Super League match against Manchester United at Etihad Stadium. The WSL attendance record was smashed with 31,213 people watching the first Manchester derby of Women’s Super League era – nearly six times the previous WSL record Getty 35/50 6 September 2019 A bull bumps into a plain clothes police officer (left) while being walked by Prime Minister Boris Johnson during his visit to Darnford Farm in Banchory near Aberdeen. It coincided with the publication of Lord Bew's review and an announcement of extra funding for Scottish farmers PA 36/50 5 September 2019 First Minister Nicola Sturgeon cuts the hair of David Torrance MSP raising £1000 for the charity Maggie's Centre in Kirkcaldy at the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh PA 37/50 4 September 2019 Australia's David Warner looks dejected after being dismissed by England's Stuart Broad during day one of the fourth Ashes Test at Old Trafford in Manchester Getty 38/50 3 September 2019 Anti Brexit demonstrators attend a protest at Parliament Square. Lawmakers returned from their summer recess Tuesday for a pivotal day in British politics as they challenged Prime Minister Boris Johnson's insistence that the UK leave the European Union on 31 October, even without a withdrawal agreement to cushion the economic blow AP 39/50 2 September 2019 Set building begins on Waterloo Place in Edinburgh ahead of filming for Fast and Furious 9 PA 40/50 1 September 2019 Members of the Royal Southern Yacht Club and the Island Sailing Club take part during the annual cricket match between the clubs, which takes place on the Bramble Bank sandbank in the middle of the Solent at low tide PA 41/50 31 August 2019 Anti-Brexit protesters demonstrate at Whitehall in London SWNS 42/50 30 August 2019 One of the iconic 'Girl with Balloon' artworks by anonymous street artist Banksy is carried near one of the original locations the artwork appeared at on the Southbank in London AP 43/50 29 August 2019 The sun rises over the sculpture "The Couple" by artist Sean Henry, at Newbiggin-by-the-sea in Northumberland PA 44/50 28 August 2019 A person wearing a Boris Johnson 'head' digs a grave at the foot of a tombstone during a protest organised by Avaaz and Best for Britain, outside Downing Street in London PA 45/50 27 August 2019 Nat Lofthouse statue is covered in flags at the University of Bolton Stadium, Bolton Action Images via Reuters 46/50 26 August 2019 Performers take part in Notting Hill Carnival. Nearly one million people were expected to attend Sunday and Monday's carnival to celebrate Caribbean culture AFP/Getty 47/50 25 August 2019 A competitor swims in the World Bog Snorkelling Championships in Llanwryd Wells, Powys Reuters 48/50 24 August 2019 People flock to Bournemouth beach as a heatwave spells potentially record high temperatures for the bank holiday weekend PA 49/50 23 August 2019 Fans of Bury FC deliver a symbolic coffin to the club's home at Gigg Lane as the continuation of their membership to the football league lies in doubt. The club will lose their membership at midnight if they don't find a buyer or prove that they have the means to pay off their debts PA 50/50 22 August 2019 Labour Leader Jeremy Corbyn and Shadow DEFRA Secretary Sue Hayman during a visit to Rakefoot Farm, Castlerigg, Keswick where they are highlighting the danger of a No Deal Brexit to sheep farmers PA

“You [the UK government] have a legal obligation to investigate and to prosecute.”

Mr Melzer, who is an expert in international law and has been deputy head of delegation at the International Committee of the Red Cross, said the government’s refusal to hold an inquiry is a “scandalous” breach of the law and a move towards “disabling democracy.”

He is concerned the government is blocking the judicial investigation to protect senior officials who he believes may have authorised the involvement.

“It’s not some rogue soldier going crazy … killing a prisoner somewhere in Afghanistan because he’s mentally disturbed,” he said.

“Here, we’re talking about a policy of co-operating with torture and rendition and that goes very high up.

“It’s impossible that it was not green-lighted or at least tolerated by top officials. And obviously that’s where every government starts drawing lines, and they don’t want to investigate.”

Independent news email Only the best news in your inbox Enter your email address Continue Continue Please enter an email address Email address is invalid Fill out this field Email address is invalid Email already exists. Log in to update your newsletter preferences Register with your social account or click here to log in I would like to receive morning headlines Monday - Friday plus breaking news alerts by email Update newsletter preferences

The Reprieve legal charity and MPs David Davis and Dan Jarvis launched a judicial review over the government's “refusal” to hold the inquiry on Thursday.

Papers lodged at the High Court accused ministers of failing to deliver on promises to hold a fully independent, judge-led inquiry into alleged British complicity in US torture and extraordinary rendition as part of the “war on terror”.

They argue that the failure is irrational and violates Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights as well as common law prohibition of torture. The government must respond within 21 days.

Maya Foa, the director of Reprieve, said: “The powerful must be held to account so that victims can move on with their lives, but just as importantly because if we do not fully investigate our past mistakes, we are doomed to repeat them.”

Mr Davis, a veteran Conservative MP and former minister, accused the government of “years of dither and delay”.

“Torture doesn’t produce reliable intelligence, and involvement in it makes everyone in this country less safe,” he said.

“We must take a clear-eyed look at this dark period in our recent history, and give victims the redress and accountability they were promised, and face the future with a clear conscience and determination not to repeat the mistakes of the past.”

Parliament’s Intelligence and Security Committee published two reports in June 2018 which revealed the UK’s oversees intelligence service MI6 and the domestic spy agency MI5 were involved in hundreds of torture cases and scores of rendition cases since 9/11. Although they found no evidence of abuse directly carried out by UK personnel, a key passage in the reports said then foreign secretary Jack Straw authorised MI6 for the cost of funding a plane which was involved in an individual rendition case, raising questions about the involvement of senior officials.

Committee chair Dominic Grieve said it was forced to end its investigation early because then Prime Minister Theresa May denied it access to key intelligence officials and witnesses. The committee decided to publish their findings in 2018 and called for the government to establish an inquiry into the matter “without further delay.”

The same year the British government officially apologised to a Libyan man, Abdul Hakim Belhaj, for the role MI6 played in kidnapping and renditioning him and his pregnant wife to Muammar Gaddafi’s Libya in 2004. The couple were taken from Malaysia to Thailand, tied to the floor of a military transport and flown to Libya, where they were imprisoned – and Mr Belhaj, who was a known enemy of Gaddafi, was tortured.

Letters from MI6 counter-terrorism head at the time, Sir Mark Allen, were found by Human Rights Watch in 2011 after Gaddafi’s downfall and revealed the agency was involved.

“This was the least we could do for you and for Libya to demonstrate the remarkable relationship we have built over the years … The intelligence about… [Belhaj] was British. I know I did not pay for the air cargo. But I feel I have the right to deal with you direct on this,” a fax from Mr Allen said.

On 18 July, Cabinet Office minister David Lidington announced the government would not hold a judge-led inquiry into torture and rendition telling the House of Commons it has “no legal obligation” or “policy reason” to launch one. He added that the guidance and training for UK personnel dealing with detainees who are held by others has been revised.

Mr Melzer said the decision to rule out the inquiry is both illegal and a threat to the separation of powers because the government is dominating the other two branches of the state, the judiciary and Parliament over the torture investigation, which sets a dangerous precedent if unchallenged.

“We’re creating absolute power,” Melzer told The Independent.

“We know … from history, a government that has unchecked power will abuse that power … we’re allowing people to abuse their power and this can escalate to the worst. So we’re clearly not there yet … But once we’re there it’s too late.”

The UK Foreign Office (FCO) referred The Independent to the statement by Mr Lidington on 18 July which said, “The Government do not participate in, solicit, encourage or condone the use of torture or of cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment ... To do so … would also be a betrayal of everything that we stand for as a nation.

“There is no policy reason to… [hold an inquiry], given the extensive work already undertaken to improve policies and practices in this area. The Government’s position is also that there is no legal obligation.”

Kenneth Clarke, MP and co-chair of the all party parliamentary group (APPG) on extraordinary rendition, told The Independent it’s a “cover-up” and senior officials are hiding in the “long grass”.

“They don’t want to reveal who took the decisions, what authorisation they have, what was the policy that led to us abandoning our normal prohibitions on being involved with torture or being involved with forceful rendition,” he said.

Mr Clarke took a leading role setting up the present ISC with more powers and believes the government “ground it to a halt,” because “it was getting too far … exposing too much” and was looking in depth into things that were “really worrying” including authorisation and motive. He has spoken to members of MI6 and the government about the need for an inquiry. One MI6 official whom Mr Clarke declined to name reportedly argued: “Well it’s all so long ago. It’s all so different now. That doesn’t happen like that now. It’s all changed. Don’t worry, it’s fine.”

Others in government reportedly told him there have been too many public inquires and they cannot spend millions of pounds on another. “I’m afraid I think that’s a cover-up,” Mr Clarke said.

Lord Robin Hodgson, who works on the APPG for extraordinary rendition alongside Mr Clarke, said public interest in the issue has been worn out, adding the security services are using their “ace of trumps” which is the argument that “this is keeping the country safe minister.”

Former MI5 officer and whistleblower Annie Machon told The Independent she agreed it bore the hallmarks of a cover-up, adding the intelligence agencies have been “caught with their pants down.” She said in the nineties MI5 had an “older tribal knowledge” from experience in Ireland that torture was counter-productive, produced blowback and was an unethical recruiting drum for terrorists, so they avoided it.

But after 9/11 the US went “helter-skelter” down the path of extraordinary renditions and extrajudicial killings and the UK agencies with their close working relationship quickly followed.

There was also tension among the British agencies, with the head of MI5 Baroness Eliza Manningham-Buller pushing back against the use of torture, extraordinary rendition and war with Iraq arguing it was dangerous for national security while MI6 head Richard Dearlove was more willing to do what the Blair government wanted, she added.

Senior officials have been protected while MI6 officers who might have come forward about torture and rendition during the Chilcot inquiry were not given a chance, Ms Machon added.

She believes the Belhaj case contains some of the most damning and disturbing evidence of UK involvement in torture and rendition after 9/11.

“I think because they’ve been caught out now particularly with the Belhaj case… That has caused massive embarrassment,” she said.

“So I would assume that both agencies have pulled back… again from the idea of ever being involved in torture.”

The UN special rapporteur hasn’t yet had a reply to his 19 August letter, which he said is unusual when dealing with the UK and the other “mature democracies.”

The Foreign Office told The Independent they still have time to reply before the deadline, adding that through the FCO’s Magna Carta Fund for Human Rights and Democracy they have supported “over £500,000 of programmes aimed at preventing torture around the world”. source